Ad Here  
Payment banks have arrived Lacklustre credit expansion Small finance banks offer high interest rates Growing gainfully Emerging crisis Holy or unholy? What is the priority – mergers or NPA reduction? Who is the real beneficiary? Perhaps small is more beautiful than big! Drastic decline in asset quality The collaboration suite of cyber criminals Thirty more cities seek to become SMART Stage set for Indian ‘avatar’ of foreign banks All that glitters is not gold... The paradox: clamour for the Goliath and David Grows Bigger It’s a war on black money, support it. Drop in SLR- sparing lendable resources Reaching out: is it slowing down? Monetary policy continues to adopt dis-inflationary path United India Insurance - Rs 110 crore losses have been claimed till now due to floods in Tamil Nadu Ferrying digital banking to Lakshadweep One down in private sector Nothing much can happen…. New bank licences, at last... Too big to fail and too small to sail Needed a Banking Atlas Anytime banking to anywhere banking Rationalised Well-lived... Cautious and considerate Small finance payment banks... Cradle of banks to a smart city... Insatiable appetite for credit Banking on Risk Two banks: their jubilees and performances Smart banking in smart cities Greet Lakshmi the banking robot How ‘secure’ are the secured loans? Banking in Telangana Merger mania haunts banks Another route for achieving financial inclusion A bank for women, by women Financial inclusion vs unclaimed deposits A new development bank rising in the east… From lazy banking to easy banking LVB- A supermarket of financial services Cut in repo rate – lower than expected Banking overhauling or reorganisation? Good, bad and ugly Small is ‘more’ beautiful Indian customers are tech savvy Ernakulam excels... How okay are new banks? Big bank merger, bigger expectations Fund healthcare clinics in villages... New capitals of Migrant banks Aadhaar, niraadhaar and banking A development bank for BRICS Capital base of regional rural banks raised Governance in Reverse Gear? Targets continue to be ad hoc Bottomlines shrink, bad loans rise... Why any time money? Bank deposits account for 46.3 per cent of household savings Just 660 days! Target over-ambitious... Why priority status? Mega merger is on Reaching the Unreached… Growing volume of stressed assets… Managing NPAs... Hesitancy in announcing year-end results
Perhaps small is more beautiful than big!

Currently in India, 17 public sector banks and one private sector bank act as  ‘parent entities’ to 56 gramin banks. These parents sponsor gramin banks by owning 35 per cent of their paid-up capital and also provide parental care by sending their chairmen and a few senior executives on deputation to the gramin banks. 

The performances of these gramin banks are contrasting. After their recent amalgamation at the state level, a few of them which were incurring losses, have become stronger and vibrant. However, among the parent banks, there are a few who are in the red because of the heavy burden of NPA. Here is a  comparative assessment of the performance of a  parent bank,  vis-a-vis a  gramin bank sponsored by it.  

The banks selected are Indian Overseas Bank and Pandyan Grama Bank. The two sets of banks are not comparable because of the operational diversities.  Gramin banks have restricted operations in their lending rates, size and amount of loans. Their areas of operations are stipulated and confined to few, selected districts in a single state. On the other hand, parent banks have the freedom to branch out to any part of the country. A major number of their branches are operating in urban and metropolitan centres. However,  a broad comparison reveals some interesting features of their performances.


IOB and its gramin...

IOB has an NPA of 13.99 per cent, one of the highest among its peers.  Juxtapose this against Pandyan Grama Bank’s nil NPA ratio. Pandyan has been presenting a nil NPA ratio for the last 13 years continuously! This zero NPA is a record, which no bank can boast. The achievement has been attained despite having a credit-deposit ratio as high as 81.40 per cent, while its recovery rate is 97.67 per cent. The NPA of IOB is Rs.19,749 crore. There has, however, been an improvement in its NPA position, as indicated in its latest Directors’ Report.

The parent bank has a total business of Rs 368,119 crore while the smaller bank has Rs.10,052 crore only as on 31 March 2017. IOB has a wider network of 3373 branches both spread all over the country and on foreign soil. Pandyan Bank has only 317 branches confined to 16 districts in Tamil Nadu. Rural branches constitute 52 per cent of the total branches of Pandyan Bank while in the case of IOB, it is only 27 per cent. Yet, the small bank has made a net profit of Rs. 74 crore, while its sponsor bank has incurred a loss of Rs.3417 crore during the year.    

Let’s look at another gramin bank in Tamil Nadu - Pallavan Grama Bank, sponsored by Indian Bank. With a smaller volume of credit lent, Rs.2904 crore, its net NPA ratio is only 0.75 percent, while the NPA of its parent bank is much higher at 4.39 per cent.


Other small banks in Tamil Nadu

Tamil Nadu has four banks in the private sector. They have been operating for a longer period than the gramin banks. The oldest of the four, City Union Bank, has a NPA ratio of 1.71 percent and its total advances are Rs. 21,112 crore. Tamilnadu Mercantile Bank is having a volume of Rs. 21,972 crore as advances, has contained its NPA ratio at 1.74 per cent. KVB’s NPA ratio is  2.53 per cent with an outstanding level of loans at Rs.41,424 crore. LVB has a slightly higher NPA ratio of 2.84 per cent for its advance level of Rs.23,729 crore. All the four banks have been able to contain their NPA ratios at ‘reasonable’ levels.    


Inferences from the comparison

One significant conclusion is that the large advances of bigger banks have increased stressed assets.  As with IOB’s  share of Rs.108 crore in the total non-performing advances of Kingfisher Airlines, most of the large loans by bigger banks have a similar story. Without generalising, it may be said that small banks have a better record of credit management. The clamour for bigger banks brings with it the risk of creating huge non-performing assets over a period. Small, perhaps is more beautiful than big! n

Author :
Reported On :
Sector :
Shoulder :
IE, the business magazine from south was launched in 1968 and pioneered business journalism in south. Through the 45 years IE has been focusing on well-presented and well-researched articles. When giants in the industry stumbled to keep pace with the digital revolution, IE stayed affixed embracing technology.
Read more
Economist Communications Ltd is committed to ensuring that your privacy is protected.
Read more
You agree that your use of this Website and the purchase of the magazine will be governed by these terms and conditions.
Read more
S-15, Industrial Estate,
Chennai - 600 032.
PHONE: +91 44 22501236