Ad Here  
Benevolent businessthan... Lingayats get a reminder: it’s poll time Come to Tamil Nadu where the action is... Strike over salary hike All these happened in TN… Time to wake up Launch of ins vikrant, India’s first indigenous aircraft carrier Illegal mining of sand SIPB clears big proposals Monsoon fury States - Kerala KNPP with the grid State under siege Enchanting and enterprising Tamil Nadu Competing for good: Tale of two states States - Odisha Info-Park, more space Winds of change... KCR’s I-day bonanza Bringing magic of Rajasthan alive Mango Diplomacy Divide & Prosper TN to suffer serious loss Technology has raised the bar... Development depends on land availability... Bus services hit Waste disposal model A blueprint for the future When business flocks to MP... It’s Karnataka chalo for Amit Shah? Flurry of collaborations inked by AP AP in better shape Stirring the political cauldron A year of Telangana A giant push for millets More government apps Miners asked to pay more State Forward Why the Congress won in Karnataka Infrastructure to the FORE Wouldn’t the Mahatma like clean restrooms in our cities! Global Investors Meet Post Poned Vedanta to close Lanjigarh refinery Promise of a productive year Of development and welfare ODISHA Deputy Collector Sindhu! TN can leverage NLC’s strengths... Bhubaneswar IIT cries for completion Power for all Green crimes galore A neta at it again! KTR releases Annual Report Doubling production and tripling farmers’ income... Hype on Hyperloop Global meets galore Thalaivaa ‘E’ for enterprise Tasks for the new government Bifurcation yet to end water wars It indeed is attractive for investments MOUs worth Rs.10.54 lakh crore signed Municipal Elections Land acquisition policy is ahead of national policy... Leaky old lorries, mini cabs for techies... CII to set up tourism bureaus MCL has a taste of judicial activism! States Roundup Kochi Metro Rail Project City of foaming lakes and fire Fanciful Rao and tech-savvy Naidu Land scams rock AP & TS An industrious idea With agriculture at its heart... Oh, la la. Homestays, a budding tourism industry Infra boost to the new capital Reducing carbon footprint... Pioneering education model TN to suffer serious loss State of the States Nod to cow slaughter bill Enticing pest traps Industrial corridors to boost economy Inter-State boundary
TN to suffer serious loss
The recommendations of the Fourteenth Finance Commission (FFC) are unfavourable to Tamil Nadu: estimated annual loss of Rs 6000 crore.

In a well-reasoned analysis, a press note issued by the Commissionerate of Planning explains the drop in the share in the divisible pool of Central taxes: the 13th Finance Commission fixed this at 4.97 per cent whereas in the FFC it has come down to 4.02 per cent resulting in a sizeable loss.

 Tamil Nadu Chief Minister represented the FFC to increase the share of the state in the divisible pool of Central taxes. There is, satisfaction that the FFC has recommended a increase of states’ share from 32 per cent to 42 per cent.


Adverse impact of change in criteria

 The FFC changed the formula for devolution giving weightage of 17.5 per cent for population in 1971, 15 per cent for area, 10 per cent for demographic change in 2011 and 50 per cent for income distance.

 Better attention to population growth paid by Tamil Nadu is penalised by this change. Tamil Nadu has moved to a small family norm and thus a lower weightage for 1971 population (from 25 per cent to 17.5 per cent) adversely affects this.  The increase in the area criterion from 10 per cent to 15 per cent is another point of discomfort. The state points to the protection of smaller states by a minimum two per cent share. Tamil Nadu’s share in the weighted area at 3.373 per cent does not attend to the higher density of population.  Likewise, weightage for the forest cover also adversely affects Tamil Nadu which has only 3.32 per cent forest area.

 Income distance criterion of 50 per cent weightage understandably favours poorer states many of which have also performed poorly in terms of fiscal prudence and efficiency. The press note points to the three-year average per capita GSDP for 2010-11 to 2012-13 for Tamil Nadu at Rs 98,237, is more than 50 per cent over the national average of Rs 64,290.


Prudent fiscal management punished

Under the income distance criterion of the FFC, Tamil Nadu’s share works out to just 2.689 per cent relating to a population share of 5.96 per cent. This has grievously affected the state.

For decades Tamil Nadu has been known for its prudent fiscal administration. There is, understandably disappointment and resentment over the lack of recognition to this aspect.

Author :
Reported On :
Sector :
Shoulder :
IE, the business magazine from south was launched in 1968 and pioneered business journalism in south. Through the 45 years IE has been focusing on well-presented and well-researched articles. When giants in the industry stumbled to keep pace with the digital revolution, IE stayed affixed embracing technology.
Read more
Economist Communications Ltd is committed to ensuring that your privacy is protected.
Read more
You agree that your use of this Website and the purchase of the magazine will be governed by these terms and conditions.
Read more
S-15, Industrial Estate,
Chennai - 600 032.
PHONE: +91 44 22501236