Ad Here  
Paytm karo... A welcome initiative by the judiciary Bihar – Nitish Kumar adopts the Lalu model West Bengal: mindless malignancy TGS- The king storyteller Bihar elections - the Rajaji formula worked A rich pool of talent not utilised…. China invests in India No Maha Koottani in TN... EVM is tamper-proof Silver Years of Madras Musings Kulandai was a giant A Grand Finale for SN’s MS centenary at the US… Return to king coal for urea... Russi Mody – a tribute The brown list of Venkitaramanan Streamlining mandatory third party cover PPP mode for upgrading Corporation Hospitals Which side are you, Montek? The few handicaps... Building loyalty through the stomach Welcome thrust on trade in Modi’s foreign visits... Air Asia India will set new benchmarks for budget travel Road development slows down Polls and promises Tribute MHC should not return to its old indisciplined ways Recognition to role of NBFCs.... Naidu will soon build a new Hyderabad Should we change the official year? Parliament in paralysis... Robber barons everywhere Liberal imports idling indigenous capacities The star of Spencers is no more Online not in line with brick and mortar businesses... Increasing non co-operation of state leaders Revive development banks... Protest masters... The rise and rise of KCP Contrarian cousins The nuclear option All eyes on Sankara Nethralaya Music happens Make standards certification mandatory... For whom the bell tolls? Medical costs hit the roof... Eternal support for capitalisation of PS banks Tatas moving out of urea production... Build close rapport with business leaders Welcome changes that testify to Jayalalithaa’s return to health Wanted: a second airport for Chennai Things happen by accident and not by design... IPL type auction for VCs? Wise Presidents A C Muthiah – his munificent bequeaths to science Scientists urged to take up farmer-oriented research Fall in crude prices help in oil sector reform Lesson from Chandrababu Naidu He continues the focus on social amelioration Measuring roof tops in terms of KW/MW The balancing act Delhi is distant Moily’s bold thrust L&T: focus on infrastructure and more infrastructure… Infrastructure funding – lessons learnt Adharma of opposition politics Secularism and anti-Hinduism Adapt Vajpayee dinner diplomacy Shaming of Tamils by Tamil farmers at Delhi Editor's Says Odisha: spectacular win by Naveen Patnaik An enemy’s enemy is a friend Readers' Mail Small units prefers to remain small... Airlines in India: cost and space Padma Bhushan for A Ramakrishna Sri Lanka votes for change CRS, a jewel among managers, is no more. Boy, can you beat these? Muffled voices for merit… The sea- saw battle continues... GM Technology at last! Rs.1600 crore paper board plant of TNPL Delhi returns to BJP to the lack of interest on the part of these to focus on original research. This despite the much lower costs of such research in India. The industry which thrived on the protection of a closed economy and the advantage of a vast domestic market, has failed to organise its evolution on healthy lines Delhi Chalo... For whom the MIDS bell tolls? Nuclear power at the nucleus Excel Generators provide the vital back-up When the President was rendered homeless… Marketing expert Balagopal is no more Alexa – Talking Wikipedia Discoms deserve better… Sweet news for TN sugar mills A friendly business group Multi-faceted Venkat Solar thermal shines… The Swadeshi Trump TN-leverage strength of BHEL, NLC... Colour-Chem’s colourful KRVS Tribute – M V Murugappan Reliance’s TV – 18 ready to launch Tamil News Channel Poor quality of university VCs Solar, solar everywhere … He saved millions from starvation... More tributes to GR The why of tax incentives TIAM turns a full cycle Put expensive assets created to use... Quality education through the PPP mode A more liberated TN… WTO Meet: resolved to meet again When Ratan Tata visited SRM Breaththrough in malaria control Tihar, Puzhal not different from Parappana Agrahara A glass full of corruption Don’t seem to feel the pulse… TN – agglomerate land holdings without alienating ownership Fuel for thought The ‘Jayanthi Tax.’ Quality silica from Neyveli The Jan Dhan bonanza CII projects higher growth… Come elections, come advertisements... CSR and CMI: promise of another Srinivasan Ramanujan... Focus on quality of power - its only around 170-180V Maximising the micro pricing … When online building permits work…. Varuna (rain) in 2015; Vaayu (air) in 2016. Chennai devastated Welcome focus on core competence Tax agriculture R Sridhar steps down as CEO of Shriram Capital Of course, Gujarat is vibrant Naidu’s return augurs well for Seemandhra Kinetic Karnataka Shipping woes of Chennai companies Tatas moving out of urea production... Modi storms Silicon Valley There was flood of milk. Reason: no milk commissioner! Not just in-laws (and outlaws); they’ve renowned academics at the helm! Kudos to NDTV... Tribute – Manikam Ramaswami Diamond jubilee of Egmore Samskrt School Mersal magnified Valli, they are more marginalised Limit foreign borrowings to hi-tech, export potential projects... Chennai and Kolkata miss opportunity to grow as Delhi and Mumbai L&T- the specialty of special purpose vehicles Modi and the lady CIPET hqrs to stay at Guindy – for the present? Permanent secretariat for TN GIM No mega rail project for Tamil Nadu TELANGANA at last…BUT Remembering Indira Sivasailam... Computation of GDP – conundrums continue Preserving for the future Waning interest in public discussions… The power-full Hindujas Lalu’s envy, India’s pride ONGC at KG Basin Fortune for Indian Airlines More Shakti to resource mobilisation... Pharma – overdose of copying London, London Narayan Cleaning Ganga – relocate tanneries and install electric crematoria This scant respect for Law A Grand Finale for SN’s MS centenary at the US… Towards speedy justice A yen for wastage… An informal presentation - analytical, forward locking... IAS invades NDDB... Making ‘my Amaravati’... Whistle-Stop Tour of Raghuram Rajan S Ramanathan – a versatile musician, musicologist Editor's Notes Shale gas and its shallow future Godspeed, Chief Minister JJ Intellectual of rare qualities More Shakthi to Das’ elbow A proud Madrasi S V Raju – a ‘good’ true liberal Why this malaise in medical education? Haul over the coal Align crops to agro climate endowments… Like Hinduism: many paths to reach God... Delhi is distant… Five star activism stalls development activity Dr C Rangarajan returns to Chennai Vibrant Gujarat GNS - 100: our first subscriber A professional at the helm of IRDA... Why land prices zoom in TN? Auto components surge… Strengthen the base... Tough task taking states together An inexplicable neglect Banning booze... The Gulf aviation boom Convulsions in The Hindu F C Kohli - his concerns all embracing Engineering seats go abegging …and of a popular trade leader Gay abandon in pricing When nations steal growth from one another… Shanti and Sadhana through Music Where a state respects its litterateurs… Another Indian music maestro at the UN Insurance companies bleeding, yet no decision on increasing FDI limit! Cutting the nose to spite the face Funding the un-funded Fortune 500 review Tribute – UCAL Selvan… Noble nonagenarians... The rise and fall of Annamalai University Sweeter prospects for sugar SoA @ 80 Welcome GST Plummeting profits of PSBs EEC at the National Media Centre When TN politicians can emulate Kerala's A think tank for Chennai When small is no larger beautiful.. Revving up the manufacturing sector PC’s preference for professionals Telangana in top gear… More heat than light The Ports’ Pasha expands into Tamil Nadu Poor representation for Kerala and TN in Cabinet Demise of a media baron... Inflation: are we emulating Argentina and Brazil? New IT products of Ramco in the pipeline… Rahman at CIC Roaring Ro-Ro facility Mu Sigma – is no more How Air-India loses customs... Cement prices continue to rise… The ‘Ayyo-yes’ is no more Land reclamation from sea appears cheaper! No engine for this car Where is Rajaji? B H Kothari - a tribute Gas is the way forward IPL - no surprise this scam TN accounts for the largest recruits by the IT sector
The brown list of Venkitaramanan

Such a facility has also been utilised by powerful corporates and wealthy educational institutions exploiting the loopholes in the legal system and delaying decisions as long as possible. Of course, these could afford the services of legal luminaries at exorbitant fees.

I remember such luminaries helped large corporates like ITC to defer tax liability over long periods in the 1980s. One of the issues was the excise duty levied on goods produced. ITC and large vehicle manufacturers like Tata Motors used to transfer stocks to warehouses in different states paying excise duty on factory gate manufacturing costs that were kept low. The costs were marked up from the warehouses to distributors and dealers ends causing sizeable losses in excise revenue. These added up to around Rs 800 crore plus for ITC alone. Large number of other manufacturers of goods followed this practice by resorting to litigation. Legal luminaries like N A Palkivala provided needed relief to the corporates. The plea of the tax collectors had no effect and the economy went downhill reaching the nadir in 1991. 

The brilliant civil servant S Venkitaramanan thought of dealing with these in an unconventional way. As finance secretary, he sat over the files of the Tatas who had to get the government’s clearance for importing a mothballed steel plant from Europe. This had to be done within a deadline and the file wouldn’t move. Venkitaramanan succeeded in persuading the company to cough up a portion of the disputed bulging tax claims! When he was asked at the Economic Editors’ Conference whether it was a sort of a black listing of such firms, in his characteristic humour he responded: “you can call it the brown list.” 

Like what Jerome K Jerome said, the method may be crude but it was effective.

Reported On :
Sector :
IE, the business magazine from south was launched in 1968 and pioneered business journalism in south. Through the 45 years IE has been focusing on well-presented and well-researched articles. When giants in the industry stumbled to keep pace with the digital revolution, IE stayed affixed embracing technology.
Read more
Economist Communications Ltd is committed to ensuring that your privacy is protected.
Read more
You agree that your use of this Website and the purchase of the magazine will be governed by these terms and conditions.
Read more
S-15, Industrial Estate,
Chennai - 600 032.
PHONE: +91 44 22501236