Ad Here  
Chinese smart phones flourish in small towns too! Michelin to double Chennai capacity Back in growth mode Consolidating leadership position in smartphones Welcome focus to improve rural India... The unexpected exit Ponni Sugars (Erode) Ltd: not so sweet 2012-13 L&T profit up by 11 per cent Rane targets Rs.5500 crore topline by 2018-19 HPCL plans Rs.61,000 crore capex over 5-years Mercedes-Benz sales continue to zoom L & T’s floating dock for navy When small is not so beautiful… Are they really independent? It takes two to tango Smartphone onslaught by Chinese brands AL introduces Guru & Partner ITC chairman calls for policy impetus to transform agriculture AL secures orders for 3600 buses Eyes strong growth in 2016-17 Hindalco – re-rating The gainers and the losers Preparing for the next growth curve Increasing market share Last stages TVS Automobile invests Rs.75 crore in start-up firms TN government keen on revival of operations at Nokia complex He excels in the nuts and bolts of entrepreneurship Emami – a new growth mantra Toyota and Suzuki to introduce EVs in India by 2020 Solar installations exceed 2015 capacity in five months M & M unveils driverless technology for tractors Singur minus Nano – victory or folly? Smooth sailing of SAIL TVS Srichakra plans capacity expansion Tata Motors aims to be among the Top 3 global CV & PV firm Aurobindo Pharmacy: good turnaround RoC in the dock... A niche in FMCG business... Carnival Films acquiring 3000 screens pan India Tata Motors charts investments in PV and CV businesses Land wars Daimler grows sales and share in India Ode to Ratan Tata Sundram Fasteners rejigs international A welcome initiative-even critics are recognised Vellayan is back, after 150 days Sivasankaran enters taxi space to take on Uber and Ola ITC – steep excise hike AL wins Deming prize again Gamesa to set up a plant in Nellore Wabco launches safety system Tata gets 4-star rating for Zest Right to privacy – now it’s fundamental! Housing demand revival Record two-wheeler sales 29 per cent jump in TCS revenues Tata Motors bets on new launches IOB on turnaround path V-Guard launches app-enabled water heater system Daimler’s truck exports from Chennai cross 5000 units Tata Steel, ThyssenKrupp sign MoU to merge European units PPP model for infrastructure development Nissan exit shouldn’t affect ALL Titan Company – sales recovery to kick in E.I.D Parry (India) Ltd: another sweet year Maruti – for young buyers TI Cycles plans retail expansion to drive sales for premium bicycles From the toughest to the best year Yamaha unveils scooter boutique Bajaj Finserv – Q1: fare well L & T set bigger ambitions in defence business Hyundai to focus on SUVs and AMT variants L&T bags the Mumbai Trans-harbour link order Forging industry worried over lower supply of steel and its price Dish TV – subscriber additions encouraging CAPITAL NOTES New India Assurance posts impressive show Tata Motors joins compact SUV bandwagon with Nexon LVB posts 31 per cent growth in Q1 net profit PSU non-life firms seek to protect share Kone India eyes further growth in elevator market Hyundai India achieves 7 mn production at Chennai factory Is this a generation gap? Shriram Life clocks more than Rs.1000 crore premium in 2015-16
Is this a generation gap?
After a hired professional and major shareholder had charged India’s holy cow, Tata Sons, of not following corporate governance, another crisis has emerged. This time a founder and principal shareholder is making the charge on hired professionals. The company: Infosys.

Infosys is in the limelight after the founders, in particular, doyen N R Narayana Murthy, questioned the corporate governance and ethical practices of its top management. At question was the payment of Rs. 17.38 crore to former-CFO Rajiv Bansal on his exit from Infosys and shelling out six times the  target company’s revenue for the acquisition of Panaya.  SEBI is examining a whistleblower’s letter and responses from the management to see if there is any breach of Securities laws. The owners, including N R Narayana Murthy, believe that the ethics and governance of the company have deteriorated. He in fact questioned if there was any ‘hush money’ involved in the severance pay of Rajiv Bansal, which was significantly higher than the amount mentioned in his contract.


A merger and a goodbye

Does Rajiv Bansal who worked with Infosys for 17 years and severed after taking up the CFO role deserve a severance of about one crore for each year of service he has put in the company! That looks quite a bit out of proportion than you would normally expect. Another catch is that none of the former CFOs or senior executives had ever received such a princely sum when they exited the company. The current severance pay policy allows a 100 per cent variable component. Ironically, employees who are still contributing to the group only receive 80 per cent variable pay!  There is also a question on Vishal Sikka’s variable compensation package. The top eight executives were paid Rs 24 crore as compensation with a variable component of 20 crore plus stock options last year.  That’s not the kind of culture that Infosys grew up. 


Issue  governance and ethics

Clearly, the issue is about governance and ethics.  Apparently, Bansal’s contract stood modified without clearance from the audit and compensation committees and shareholders. Two, the payout happened without a formal board approval. Three, Bansal has allegedly received 30 months’ salary despite his contract approving a payout of only three months.  Four, according to SEBI rules, transactions involving KMP  have to be disclosed as soon as they happen and details of this operation should be disclosed at the board’s quarterly corporate governance report. While Rajiv left Infosys in October 2015, the severance was disclosed only in May 2016. And five, the transaction, being such a huge amount can be assumed to be a non-arms length transaction, which the audit committee should have disclosed. 

Infosys paid about Rs. 5 crore to Bansal and had to suspend the balance payout after a hue and cry at the company’s AGM. 

The other discontent is regarding Panaya deal, which was the first acquisition by Infosys under Vishal Sikka. Rajiv Bansal was not happy with the merger, as according to a senior formal employee involved with the purchase, the Israeli company was on the verge of shutting down and some people were laid off before the buyout. Why would an acquirer pay six times the company’s revenue for such a business? Despite the initial dissent, Infosys went ahead with the merger and denied any irregularities in the buyout. 

The founders of Infosys are ‘good capitalists’ because they were successful, earned wealth by transforming the society through innovation and ingenuity rather than inheritance or crony capitalism. Narayana Murthy defines good governance as transparency, no matter what the situation, disclosure of everything by the KMP and directors, whether good or bad, and taking action on it. 

Murthy says: “culture is the bedrock on which successful strategy rests.” He believes culture brings joy, sadness, pride and values and how people spend their time and money. A good company’s culture seeks respect from stakeholders in everything they do, concern for the society and excellence by each of the company’s employees.

The shareholders are of the opinion that the board should be proactive in communicating significant matters with major shareholders including founder shareholders as well as institutional shareholders.  They would first improve the trust of shareholders in the board. 


Ethos of founders and paid professionals

It is clear that there is a particular demarcation between the ethos of the founders and that of paid professionals. Founders seek to move forward with 100 per cent ethics, even if growth is slow. On the other hand, a paid professional is likely to overlook a few ethics to ensure he gets his compensation at any cost, as after all, he is there for a short time only! 

The crisis at the Tatas and now at Infosys raises the fundamental question whether in future founders would want to completely exit the company and leave it in the hands of hired professionals. Only time will tell if big family businesses will be easily willing to let go of their babies to someone who is there to work and earn his bread and nothing else. 

In other words, will they ever do a Larsen & Toubro?  

Author :
Reported On :
Sector :
Shoulder :
IE, the business magazine from south was launched in 1968 and pioneered business journalism in south. Through the 45 years IE has been focusing on well-presented and well-researched articles. When giants in the industry stumbled to keep pace with the digital revolution, IE stayed affixed embracing technology.
Read more
Economist Communications Ltd is committed to ensuring that your privacy is protected.
Read more
You agree that your use of this Website and the purchase of the magazine will be governed by these terms and conditions.
Read more
S-15, Industrial Estate,
Chennai - 600 032.
PHONE: +91 44 22501236